PC2024-P3 Best solutions and final results

Problem 3 – Scrap iron sorting

In total, 73 solutions were submitted for problem 3, of which 56 were correct. Congratulations to everyone who managed to solve it!

The Best Solution Awards were selected from the 19 correct solutions sent before the first hint was published. Selecting a few solutions from such a large number, most of which were written very nicely and typeset in LaTeX, was a difficult task. The main differences between the solutions were in how the magnetization M of a spherical ferromagnetic particle was calculated and in the textual explanations.

There were many solutions that were very nicely written and could have been prime choices for a best solutions award but eventually were not considered because of containing a minor mistake (that did not affect the final answer, see below) or gaps in derivation, e.g. not showing how the magnetization of a sphere was calculated. If you think you had a good solution, feel free to ask me by e-mail why your solution was not chosen.

A typical mistake that disqualified many otherwise good and nicely written solutions was an error by a numerical prefactor of the force acting on a piece of scrap, caused by a conceptual mistake in how the force was calculated. Namely, when calculating the force using the virtual displacement technique leading to the expression \vec{F}=\mathrm{grad} (\vec{B}\cdot\vec{m}), where \vec{m}=V\vec{M} denotes the magnetic dipole moment of the scrap particle. This is the correct formula, but only as long as you assume here the magnetic dipole moment \vec{m} is constant while taking the gradient. Indeed, it is clear that the force acting on a magnetic dipole does not depend on how the dipole would change if it were moved, and depends only on its instantaneous value. We can say that during a virtual displacement by a distance \mathrm{d} \vec{r}, the work done by the net force is \vec{m}\cdot \mathrm{d} \vec{B}, and the change of the dipole’s internal (potential) energy is \vec{B}\cdot \mathrm{d} \vec{m}, where \mathrm{d} \vec{m}=V\mathrm{d}\vec{M} is the change of the dipole moment caused by the displacement (one can imagine that the molecular dipoles are opposite charges that are connected with a spring in which case there is also the potential energy of the spring).

Note that the above given formula, \vec{F}=V\mathrm{grad} (\vec{B}\cdot\vec{M}) can be written so that there is no confusion about to which terms the derivative is applied to: in one-dimensional version, F_x=VM_x\frac{\mathrm{d} B_x}{\mathrm{d}x}, and in the generic case using the direct (also called the dyadic) product of two vectors producing a tensor as \vec{F}=V(\nabla\vec{B})\cdot \vec{M} (note that this formula has a dot product of the tensor \nabla\vec{B} with a vector, producing a vector).

And so, the Best Solution Awards go to the following contestants.

  • 0.3 to Luka Passek-Kumerički – a nice solution with the sphere’s magnetization derived from the electric-magnetic equivalence based on the electric field inside a homogeneously charged sphere.
  • 0.3 to Konstantin Rodionenko – a clean and compact solution with the sphere’s magnetization derived from the electric-magnetic equivalence based on the electric field inside a homogeneously charged sphere.
  • 0.3 to Kutay Kulbak – a nice solution with the sphere’s magnetization guessed and shown to be correct using magnetic scalar potential (though the expression for the force is written slightly incorrectly – although the dyadic product is apparently assumed and used later correctly, the dot stands in the wrong place).
  • 0.1 to Lukas Schicht – otherwise a very nicely written solution, but there is no explanation of where the expression for the magnetic field inside a homogeneously charged sphere comes from.

Final results for Problem 3

Pre-university students:

SaskiaPõldmaaEstoniaTallinna Reaalkool14/1/24 15:242.5937
Ilan MiheljaIvan HegedićCroatiaXV. gymnasium Zagreb, V. gymnasium Zagreb14/1/24 16:102.3579
ValKaranCroatiaXV. Gimnazija Zagreb14/1/24 18:282.1436
KutayKulbakTurkeyBahcesehir High School for Science and Technology18/1/24 05:501.9763
MihkelRannutEstoniaTallinna Reaalkool14/1/24 18:591.9487
GuyGinzbergIsraelOrt Irony Dalet Modiin15/1/24 10:131.7716
Ralf RobertPaaboEstoniaHugo Treffneri Gümnaasium15/1/24 17:521.6105
ArdaÜnverTurkeyKocaeli Gebze Bahçeşehir High School for Science and Technology21/1/24 17:231.331
FelixYewMalaysiaNational Junior College, Singapore27/1/24 05:591.21
MatejGelevNorth MacedoniaYahja Kemal27/1/24 22:111.1
TornikeTsadzikidzeGeorgiakomarovi Physics-Mathematics school29/1/24 18:380.9
Halil İbrahimYenitürkTurkeyAnkara High School of Science2/2/24 07:520.9
OytunErTurkeyKadıköy Anatolian Highschool29/1/24 13:000.9
Bahaa AldeenMelhemSyriaAlbasel Mixed High School3/2/24 22:270.9
DariusGraurMoldovaLiceul Teoretic Orizont30/1/24 09:530.9
YangguangZhengChinaThe affilicated High School of South China normal university4/2/24 11:280.9
Mohamad EidAl-aktaaSyriaAl saadeh school10/2/24 18:520.8
TomasRazbadauskasLithuaniaKaunas University of Technology Gymnasium11/2/24 16:460.7
Rares FelixTudoseRomaniaLiceul Teoretic Internațional de Informatică București11/2/24 19:430.63
ChenyunWangChinaShanghai High School17/2/24 12:580.63
AnimeshPradhanIndiaModern Delhi International School19/2/24 10:130.6
JumadurdyNuryyevTurkmenistanSpecialized Comprehensive Boarding School named after Saparmyrat Turkmenbashy in the city of Ashgabat26/2/24 05:130.5
Vincent KarlWillisAustriaBRG Innsbruck APP28/4/24 12:220.5
KaustubhKakaIndiaALLEN12/3/24 11:320.5
AndreiVilaRomaniaInternational Computer High School Bucharest7/3/24 20:490.5
RuichengMaChinaHigh School Affiliated to Harbin Teachers College5/3/24 17:100.3679

University students:

LukasSchichtGermanyEberhard Karls Universität Tübingen14/1/24 16:072.8665
KonstantinRodionenkoITMO University16/1/24 18:542.7489
LukaPassek-KumeričkiCroatiaUniversity of Zagreb17/1/24 18:342.6305
Yi-TingLinTaiwanMassachusetts Institute of Technology15/1/24 08:032.3579
Ahmet BahadırTrabzonTurkeyBoğaziçi University17/1/24 21:111.683
VadimIonasMoldovaDenmark Technical University20/1/24 12:471.6105
YUANFEIHong KongThe Hong Kong Polytechnic University21/1/24 15:091.3177
SIfat AhmedTusharBangladeshUniversity of Dhaka26/1/24 22:331.21
KarloMaksimovićCroatiaUniversity of Zagreb23/1/24 17:131.1979
Elias KoschierMichail OgnyanovAustria4/2/24 12:400.9
Kai-HsiangTuTaiwanNational Taiwan University4/2/24 11:010.9
MichałKołodziejczykPolandWarsaw University of Technology4/2/24 12:080.81
MarinusLehmannGermanyUniversity of Potsdam28/1/24 16:420.8019
NickHartmannGermanyRWTH Aachen11/2/24 12:190.72
KerimCherkezovTurkmenistanMagtymguly Turkmen State University15/2/24 10:230.7
MusaArtykovTurkmenistanMagtymguly Turkmen State University18/2/24 01:360.7
DhruvShahIndiaIndian Institute of Science27/2/24 20:270.5
DženanMidžićBosnia and HerzegovinaUniversity of Rijeka10/3/24 11:390.5
LarranceXingUnited StatesUniversity of Michigan Ann Arbor26/2/24 02:100.5
Bayram AlpSahinTurkeyBogazici University3/3/24 09:310.5
Md. BadhanMridhaBangladeshUniversity of Dhaka2/3/2024 15:390.5
RicardoOchelGermanyUniversität Heidelberg31/3/24 04:190.475
KonstantinTripunovskiNorth MacedoniaUniversity of Ljubljana – Faculty of Medicine3/4/24 15:180.3679

The list of countries:
Algeria, Argentina, Armenia, Australia, Austria, Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Belarus, Belgium, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Brazil, Bulgaria, Cambodia, Cameroon, Canada, China, Croatia, Cuba, Czech Republic, Ecuador, Egypt, El Salvador, Estonia, Finland, France, Georgia, Germany, Greece, Guatemala, Honduras, Hong Kong, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Iran, Israel, Italy, Japan, Kazakhstan, Kenya, Kosovo, Kyrgyzstan, Latvia, Lithuania, Macau, Malaysia, Mexico, Moldova, Montenegro, Nepal, Netherlands, Nigeria, North Korea, North Macedonia, Pakistan, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Romania, Russia, Rwanda, Saudi Arabia, Serbia, Singapore, Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, Sri Lanka, Suriname, Sweden, Switzerland, Syria, Taiwan, Tajikistan, Thailand, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Ukraine, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom, United States, Uzbekistan, Vietnam.